PermitsHubPermitsHub

ADUs

Can You Add a Secondary Suite to a Heritage Home in Unionville, Markham?

Yes, you can add a secondary suite to a house in Unionville or Markham Village. The suite itself is rarely the issue. The heritage review is triggered by the new door, the bigger window and the exterior stair, and those need heritage approval before Markham will issue the building permit. Here is how to tell which parts of your suite go to heritage staff and which go straight to permit.

By PermitsHub Team10 min read

Key Takeaways

  • Secondary suites are permitted in Markham's heritage conservation districts, and heritage designation does not on its own block a second unit.
  • Interior suite work such as fire separation, ceiling height, plumbing and HVAC goes straight to the building permit, while exterior changes like a new entrance, an enlarged egress window or an exterior stair usually need a heritage permit first.
  • Markham cannot issue the building permit until the heritage permit is in place, because heritage approval counts as applicable law, so the heritage file sets your real start date.
  • Suites that reuse existing openings and put new entrances on the rear or a screened side elevation tend to get approved by staff without a long committee cycle.

Suites Behind Heritage Walls

Yes. You can legally add a secondary suite to a house in Markham's Unionville or Markham Village heritage conservation districts. The heritage designation does not prohibit a second unit. What it does is put the outside of your house under review, so any exterior change the suite needs (a new side or rear entrance, an enlarged basement window for egress, an exterior stair down to the lower level, a new window well, sometimes a second meter or a wider driveway) usually requires a heritage permit from the City of Markham before the building permit can be issued. Work that stays inside the walls, such as fire separations, ceiling height and plumbing, goes straight to the building permit.

Why heritage staff care about your walls, not your basement

Unionville and Markham Village are designated under Part V of the Ontario Heritage Act. Part V districts protect the character of the streetscape and the buildings that make it up, and in practice that means exterior form: rooflines, porches, window proportions, cladding, doors and how the house sits on its lot. Each district has its own district plan with guidelines, and Markham's heritage section in Planning and Urban Design applies them, with the Heritage Markham Committee advising on files that are not straightforward.

None of that reaches the basement layout. Heritage staff are not going to ask where you put the kitchen or how you route the ductwork. The suite becomes a heritage question the moment it changes something you can see from outside, and almost every suite changes something, because a legal second unit needs its own way out and a bedroom needs a window big enough to climb through.

The suite lives in the basement, but the heritage review lives on the outside wall. Design the outside wall first and the rest of the permit follows.

Suite elements that trigger heritage review in Unionville and Markham Village

These are the items that usually send a suite file to heritage staff before the building permit can move. Whether each one needs a full review or a quick staff sign-off depends on which elevation it sits on and whether your house is identified in the district plan as contributing to the district's heritage character.

  • A new exterior door for the suite entrance, especially on a side wall that can be seen from the street.
  • An exterior stairwell cut down to a basement door, including the retaining walls, guard and railing around it.
  • Enlarging an existing basement window, or cutting a new one, so a bedroom meets Ontario Building Code egress requirements.
  • New or deeper window wells, particularly on front or exposed side elevations.
  • Replacing original windows or doors as part of the suite work, even ones that are not being enlarged.
  • A canopy, landing or porch over the new entrance.
  • Widening the driveway or adding a parking pad for the suite's tenant.
  • Visible mechanical items such as a second hydro meter, a gas meter, HRV or dryer vent terminations, and exterior lighting at the new door.

The egress window is the one that surprises people most. Plenty of older Unionville houses have small basement windows set high in a stone or block foundation. Getting a bedroom window to the code's minimum unobstructed opening often means cutting the foundation down, which changes the proportion of the opening on the elevation. On a rear wall that is usually a simple conversation. On the front of a contributing house facing Main Street Unionville, it can be a hard no, and the bedroom has to move to the back.

Elevation matters more than the change itself

The same door that sails through on a rear wall can stall for months on a street-facing side wall. In both districts the guidelines favour keeping new entrances and alterations off the primary facade and away from the parts of the house the public sees. Unionville lots along the older streets are often narrow, with side yards barely wide enough for a walkway, so the side entrance many owners want ends up both visible and tight against zoning setbacks. That double pressure is where suite projects in the core get stuck.

Work that goes straight to the building permit

Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.

If the item is entirely inside the house and changes nothing on the exterior, a Part V designation does not regulate it. These go to Markham Building Standards as part of the regular suite permit, with no heritage step.

  • Fire separations between the units, including drywall upgrades to ceilings and around stairs.
  • Rated or self-closing doors between the suite and the main house.
  • Interconnected smoke alarms and carbon monoxide alarms.
  • Ceiling height work, including underpinning or bench footings done from inside.
  • Kitchens, bathrooms, plumbing rough-ins and drain connections.
  • Separating or upgrading HVAC so smoke cannot move between units.
  • Electrical work, which also needs its own ESA permit and inspection.

There is one exception to watch for. Some houses in Unionville and Markham Village are also individually designated under Part IV of the Heritage Act, and a Part IV designation bylaw can, in rare cases, list interior features as heritage attributes. If your house has its own designation bylaw, read the list of attributes before assuming the interior is free. Most residential bylaws in these districts stick to the exterior, but a staircase or fireplace sometimes appears.

How the heritage permit fits before the building permit

Under the Building Code Act, approvals under the Ontario Heritage Act count as applicable law. In plain terms, the building examiner cannot issue your suite permit while a required heritage permit is outstanding. You can submit both, and examiners will often start their review, but the permit will not be released until heritage signs off. The order that works best in practice looks like this.

  • Confirm the house's status: inside the district boundary, how the district plan classifies it, and whether it also carries a Part IV designation.
  • Confirm zoning: that a second unit is permitted on the lot, and check side yard setbacks for any new entrance or stair, plus parking if you are widening the drive.
  • Have a pre-consultation with Markham heritage staff on the exterior moves, with photos and a rough elevation.
  • Submit the heritage permit application with existing and proposed elevations, a site plan, photos and material specifications for doors, windows, railings and wells.
  • Get the heritage decision, either delegated to staff or through the Heritage Markham Committee for anything more contested.
  • Finalize the building permit drawings to match exactly what heritage approved, then release the permit.

That last step catches people. If the heritage approval shows a wood-clad door with a particular panel layout and your building drawings show a steel slab, the examiner or the inspector will flag the mismatch. When PermitsHub prepares a suite in a heritage district, we draw the exterior elevations once and carry them into both submissions, so the heritage set and the permit set never disagree.

How long the heritage step adds

A minor, rear-facing change that staff can approve under delegated authority moves much faster than a file that has to go on a committee agenda. The Heritage Act gives the municipality a set window to decide on a complete application, and Markham staff can tell you where your file sits. Anything that needs committee time should be planned with an extra meeting cycle or two built in, especially if the committee asks for revisions. Confirm current timing with Markham's heritage section when you apply, because agendas fill up in the spring building season.

Design moves that get suite files through heritage staff faster

After working through suites on Unionville and Markham Village streets, we've found the files that move quickly share a few habits. They treat the exterior as the hard constraint and plan the floor plan around it, rather than the other way around.

  • Reuse an existing door. Many older houses already have a side or rear door to the basement or a back kitchen, and converting it is far easier to approve than cutting a new one.
  • Put the suite entrance on the rear elevation whenever the lot allows a path to it, even if that means a longer walkway.
  • Put bedrooms on the back of the basement so the egress window enlargements happen where the street cannot see them.
  • Keep new openings in proportion with the existing windows above them, aligned on the same vertical lines.
  • Specify materials that fit the house: wood or wood-look doors and windows, simple metal railings, wells that sit low and are not built up with decorative block.
  • Keep meters, vents and lighting on side and rear walls and group them, rather than scattering them across the facade.
  • Avoid widening the driveway unless you have to. It brings in landscape guidelines and often the city's tree protection rules if a tree is nearby.

Exterior stairwells deserve a specific mention. A deep stair cut beside the house with tall retaining walls and a guardrail reads as a large new structure, and on a side yard visible from the street it draws the most pushback of anything on a suite file. If the house allows the suite to share an interior stair with a proper fire separation, or a rear walkout is possible because the lot slopes, those options tend to avoid the issue entirely.

Where heritage-district suites stall

Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.

Most delays in these districts are not refusals. They are files that go back and forth because a piece was missing or the exterior was treated as an afterthought. The patterns we see repeat.

The first is assuming the house is not heritage because it is newer. Unionville and Markham Village both contain post-war and later infill houses, and owners of those homes often think the district rules skip them. They do not. A non-contributing house still sits inside the district and still needs a heritage permit for exterior alterations, although the guidelines are usually more flexible about what it can look like.

The second is starting work before approval. A contractor enlarges a basement window over a weekend, a neighbour on a heritage street notices, and now the owner is dealing with an order, a retroactive heritage application and a building permit that cannot issue until both are resolved. Heritage districts have attentive neighbours. Assume someone will notice.

The third is foundation reality. Nineteenth-century houses in both districts often sit on rubble stone or early concrete foundations with low basements. Getting enough ceiling height for a suite can mean underpinning, and enlarging a window in a stone foundation needs structural detailing that heritage staff will want to see, since the way the opening is finished shows on the outside. Get an engineer's eye on the foundation before you promise a tenant a move-in date.

The fourth is forgetting the steps that come after the permit. Markham has its own requirements for registering a second unit, and the ESA inspection is separate from the building inspections. Neither involves heritage, but both sit on the critical path to having a legal, rentable suite.

A quick way to sort your own project

Walk around your house with the suite plan in hand and ask one question at every wall: does this change anything I can see from outside? If the answer is no everywhere, you are looking at a regular building permit with no heritage step. If the answer is yes only on the rear wall, expect a short heritage review that staff can likely handle. If the answer is yes on the front or a street-facing side, budget time for a real heritage conversation and consider whether the layout can move to avoid it. If you want a second opinion before you commit to a layout, PermitsHub can review the zoning, the district plan classification and the exterior changes together and tell you which path your suite is on.

Do I Need a Permit?

1
›
2
›
3
›
4

What are you planning to build or renovate?

ADU / Garden Suite Eligibility

What type of property do you have?

Ready to move forward? PermitsHub handles permit drawings, submission, and revisions - flat-rate, GTA-wide.

Related Reading

More in this category

ADUs

FAQ

Related questions

Get started

Tell us about your project.

Free, no-pressure quote within one business day.

● Flat-rate quotes - no surprise fees

● Revisions included until approval

● Most enquiries responded to same day

Free Home Permit QuoteNo commitment · 30 sec
1
2
3

What are you building?

SCROLL TO SEE ALL 20 PERMIT TYPES

Prefer to call? 647-961-4070
CALL NOWFree Home Permit Quote30 SECONDS - NO COMMITMENT