ADUs
Fourplex Instead of a Custom Home on a Willowdale Teardown Lot
That 50-foot Willowdale bungalow lot doesn't have to become one oversized custom home. Toronto's multiplex rules let most North York teardown lots hold four units as-of-right. The permit is a different animal, though: deeper scrutiny on building depth, rated separations between units, bigger servicing questions and a development charge that lands on one unit.
Key Takeaways
- Most North York lots zoned under By-law 569-2013 can hold a fourplex as-of-right, but lots still governed by the former North York By-law 7625 need to be checked first because the multiplex permissions live in the city-wide bylaw.
- A fourplex permit adds fire-rated separations, sound-rated assemblies, unit-by-unit exiting, and electrical, water and sewer sizing reviews that a custom home never triggers.
- Under current provincial rules the second and third units are generally exempt from development charges while the fourth unit usually pays, so confirm the current treatment with the City before you finalize the unit count.
- On ravine-edge lots in Bayview and Don Mills, the TRCA and the City's ravine bylaw set the buildable envelope before multiplex zoning even comes into play.
Four Units, One Lot
Yes. On most Willowdale, Bayview and Don Mills teardown lots zoned under Toronto's city-wide By-law 569-2013, you can build a fourplex as-of-right instead of a single custom home, with no rezoning and no Committee of Adjustment hearing, as long as the building meets the multiplex standards. What changes is the permit itself. You go from a house to a small residential building, which means multiplex-specific zoning limits, fire-rated separations between units, separate exiting, bigger servicing questions and a development charge on the fourth unit. The application still goes through Toronto Building at the North York Civic Centre, but the drawings and the review are very different.
Same 50-foot lot, two very different buildings
Walk any street between Yonge and Bayview north of Sheppard and you'll see the pattern. Postwar bungalows on wide, deep lots, many of them roughly 50 feet of frontage, slowly being replaced by large two-storey custom homes that push the zoning envelope in every direction. For decades that was the only realistic outcome for these lots. The 2023 multiplex amendments changed the math. The same lot can now carry a duplex, triplex or fourplex, and the frontage that makes a custom home feel grand also makes a fourplex workable: room for a side entrance, a walkway to rear units, and a building wide enough to give four units decent layouts.
The trade-off is that a custom home is designed around one family and the zoning envelope. A fourplex is designed around the Ontario Building Code's rules for separate dwelling units, and the zoning envelope is only one of several constraints. Owners who come in expecting to swap a floor plan and keep everything else the same are usually surprised by how much of the building is driven by stairs, separations and services.
Check which zoning bylaw actually governs your lot
This is the first thing we look at on any North York teardown, and it catches people more often than you'd expect. Most of North York was brought into By-law 569-2013 when the city harmonized its zoning, but some properties still carry provisions from the former North York By-law 7625, usually because of a site-specific exception, an old appeal or a pending application at the time. The multiplex permissions were written into 569-2013. If your lot is still effectively regulated by 7625, the as-of-right path may not apply cleanly, and you could be looking at a minor variance or a more complicated zoning review.
Pull the zoning map, read any exceptions attached to your property, and check whether the lot is in an RD, RS, RT or RM zone. Detached residential zones (RD) cover most of Willowdale and the Don Mills crescents, and the multiplex rules reach into them. Also look for overlays that affect your lot: ravine and natural feature areas, and any site-specific exception numbers listed on the map. Those are what change the answer.
What the multiplex rules let you build, and where they bite
Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.
The multiplex standards aren't a blank cheque. They mostly keep the low-rise form of the neighbourhood and let you divide it into more units. In practice the rules that shape a North York fourplex are these.
- Building depth: multiplexes have their own maximum building depth, which in many zones is somewhat more generous than the detached house limit. On a deep Willowdale lot this is usually the number that decides whether you get four comfortable units or four cramped ones.
- Height and storeys: the multiplex rules keep height in line with what a new detached house in the same zone could achieve. You aren't getting a third full storey just because you're adding units.
- Floor space: the multiplex amendments relaxed floor space index limits in many residential zones, but the effect varies by zone and by any exception on your lot, so confirm before you assume the density.
- Setbacks and side yards: these generally follow the zone. On a 50-foot lot, side yards matter more for a fourplex because you often need a clear path to a side or rear entrance.
- Parking: Toronto removed most minimum parking requirements, so you aren't forced to fit four parking spaces. Many fourplex designs keep a single driveway and give the rest of the frontage to landscaping and entrances.
The building depth limit deserves special attention on custom-home-sized lots. A typical luxury rebuild on these streets pushes deep into the lot with a long main floor. A fourplex has to fit its four units within the multiplex depth, which tends to push designs toward stacked units (two up, two down) rather than four side-by-side townhouse-style units. That stacking decision drives almost everything that follows in the code review.
On a wide North York lot, the zoning envelope rarely limits a fourplex. The stairs do. Get the exiting right first and the floor plans fall into place.
What changes in the drawings: separations, exits, sound and services
A custom home permit is mostly about structure, energy efficiency, HVAC and zoning compliance. A fourplex permit asks a different set of questions, and plan examiners at the North York district office will send comments on each one if the drawings don't answer it clearly.
Fire separations between units
Each dwelling unit has to be separated from the others and from shared spaces, like a common stair or a shared furnace room, by fire separations with a rating. Floors between stacked units, walls between side-by-side units and any shared corridor all need tested assemblies. The required rating depends on the building's configuration and whether it's sprinklered, so the assembly choices should be settled before the structural drawings are finalized. Retrofitting a rated floor assembly into a framing plan that didn't anticipate it is one of the most common causes of a resubmission.
Exiting and access
Upper units need a code-compliant exit path, which usually means a dedicated stair or a protected common stair. The code limits how far an occupant can travel to an exit and sets conditions on single-exit designs. Rear units also need a clear access route from the street for firefighters. On wide lots this is easy to provide down a side yard, but it has to be shown on the site plan with the width kept clear of fences, gas meters and AC units.
Sound and smoke
Walls and floors between units need a sound transmission rating (STC 50 is the Part 9 benchmark between dwelling units), and you'll need interconnected smoke alarms and carbon monoxide alarms that meet the multi-unit requirements. Ductwork and plumbing penetrations through rated assemblies need firestopping details. Inspectors look closely at these at the framing and insulation stages.
Servicing: water, sewer, hydro and gas
This is where many fourplex budgets grow. Four kitchens and several bathrooms change the water service size and the sanitary connection, and Toronto Water will review whether the existing laterals work or need replacing. Most owners give each unit its own electrical panel and meter, which means a service upgrade coordinated with Toronto Hydro and inspected by the ESA. Separate HVAC per unit is the norm, and gas meter banks need a location that doesn't block the exit route. Garbage and recycling storage for four households also needs a home on the site plan.
Development charges and why the fourth unit is different
A new custom home pays development charges as one dwelling. Under the provincial changes in the More Homes Built Faster Act, a new house with up to two additional residential units is generally exempt from development charges on those additional units. That covers a triplex. The fourth unit sits outside that exemption in most configurations and usually attracts development charges, along with any parkland or education charges that apply.
That doesn't automatically make the fourth unit a bad idea. It means the fourth unit has to earn its keep in rent or resale value against a real added cost. Some owners build a triplex with the option to add a fourth unit later. Others build all four because the incremental construction cost of one more unit, in a building that already has rated separations and upgraded services, is modest compared with the charge. The rules and any City deferral programs have shifted more than once, so confirm the current treatment with the City before you lock in the unit count.
Ravine-edge lots in Bayview and Don Mills
Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.
A lot of the best teardown lots in this part of North York back onto ravines: the West Don and Wilket Creek around Don Mills, Burke Brook near Bayview and the East Don system east of Willowdale. On these lots the buildable area is set by natural heritage rules, not multiplex zoning.
- If the lot is within a TRCA regulated area, you need a TRCA permit, and they'll want the building kept back from the top of slope and any erosion hazard, often supported by a geotechnical slope stability report.
- The City's Ravine and Natural Feature Protection bylaw controls grading, fill and tree removal in the protected area, which affects where you can stage construction and run services.
- Private and city tree bylaws apply to larger trees anywhere on the lot, and an arborist report with tree protection zones is standard for a full rebuild.
The practical effect is that a ravine lot often loses its rear depth, which is exactly where a fourplex wants to grow. A custom home can sometimes absorb that loss by going wide. A fourplex with stacked units usually can too, but four side-by-side units rarely fit once the top-of-slope setback is drawn in. Get the TRCA staking and the slope report before you commit to a unit layout, not after.
How the two permit paths compare at the North York district office
Both projects start the same way: a zoning review, a demolition permit for the bungalow and a building permit for the new structure. Toronto generally won't let you demolish a residential building on these streets until the replacement building permit is ready to issue, so plan the sequence. After that, the paths split.
A custom home that complies with zoning moves through plan review with comments mostly on structure, energy and grading. If it needs variances, which many large North York rebuilds do, add Committee of Adjustment time and the neighbour objections that come with it. A fourplex that complies with the multiplex standards skips the Committee entirely, which can be a real time advantage, but the plan review is heavier. Expect comments on fire separation details, exiting, the servicing plan and site access. Toronto Water and Toronto Hydro reviews run alongside and can become the longest item. Inspections also add stages, with closer attention to rated assemblies and firestopping before drywall.
PermitsHub has run a steady stream of Willowdale and Don Mills rebuilds through the North York district office, and the fourplex files that move fastest share one trait: the code strategy for separations and exits was settled at the concept stage, not patched in after the first round of examiner comments. We prepare the drawings, the zoning review and the revision responses with that in mind, because a clean first submission saves more time than anything else on these projects.
So which should you build? If you plan to live in the whole house for decades and the lot has a ravine that limits depth, a custom home may still be the better fit. If you want to live in one unit and rent three, house extended family under one roof with separate front doors, or hold the property as an income building, the fourplex path is now open on most of these lots without asking anyone's permission. Just treat it as the small apartment building it is from the very first sketch.
Do I Need a Permit?
What are you planning to build or renovate?
ADU / Garden Suite Eligibility
What type of property do you have?
Ready to move forward? PermitsHub handles permit drawings, submission, and revisions - flat-rate, GTA-wide.
Our Service
Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Permit
PermitsHub handles your ADU permit application, drawings, zoning compliance, and approvals across Toronto and the GTA.
Serving This Area
Building Permits in North York
North York is one of Toronto's most diverse districts, home to everything from postwar bun…