Zoning & Bylaws
Toronto Zoning By-law 438-86: Does It Still Apply to Your Property?
Most houses in the former City of Toronto are now governed by city-wide Zoning By-law 569-2013, but 438-86 hasn't fully disappeared. Excluded lands, site-specific exceptions and prevailing by-laws can still pull your lot back under the old rules, and that changes how your setbacks, floor area and variances get calculated. Here's how to find out which by-law actually controls your project before you pay for drawings.
Key Takeaways
- For most homes in the former City of Toronto, By-law 569-2013 governs, but 438-86 can still control lands that were excluded from the city-wide by-law or that carry prevailing site-specific by-laws.
- The fastest check is the City's interactive zoning map: if your lot is shown as not part of 569-2013, or your zone label carries an exception number, you need to read further before designing anything.
- Floor area, height and building depth are measured differently under the two by-laws, so a house that complies under one can need variances under the other.
- If Toronto Building reviews your plans against both by-laws, your Committee of Adjustment application has to list and justify the variances under each one.
The Old City Rulebook
For most properties in the former City of Toronto, the old Zoning By-law 438-86 no longer governs. City-wide Zoning By-law 569-2013 does. But 438-86 still applies to some lots: lands that were left out of 569-2013 altogether, and sites where a 569-2013 exception points back to an older site-specific by-law that amended 438-86 and still prevails. If your property falls into one of those groups, your setbacks, floor area and variances are calculated under the old rules, or under both sets of rules at once.
That distinction sounds academic until a zoning examiner sends back a notice listing six variances you didn't know you needed. We see it most on semis and row houses in the old city, the Annex, Leslieville, Riverdale, Trinity Bellwoods, Cabbagetown, where the lot is tight, the house predates both by-laws, and every half metre matters.
How to Tell in Ten Minutes Which By-law Governs Your Lot
Start with the City of Toronto's interactive zoning map for 569-2013. Search your address and look at two things: whether the lot is shown as part of the by-law at all, and what the zone label says.
- If the map shows your lot as not part of By-law 569-2013, the former municipal by-law still governs. In the old city that means 438-86 plus any amendments to it.
- If you see a residential label like R (d0.6) with an x and a number at the end, you have a site-specific exception. Look that number up in Chapter 900 of 569-2013.
- Inside the exception text, look for a heading called Prevailing By-laws and Prevailing Sections. If it lists a former City of Toronto by-law, that older by-law still controls the matters it covers.
- If the label is clean, with no exception and the lot is clearly inside 569-2013, the city-wide by-law is very likely your only zoning test.
That last point is worded carefully on purpose. The map is a good first filter, not a legal opinion. The only answer Toronto Building will stand behind is the one that comes out of a zoning review, either a Preliminary Project Review, a Zoning Certificate, or the zoning examination that happens during a building permit application.
Where 438-86 Still Has Teeth
When Council passed 569-2013, it didn't sweep every parcel into the new by-law. Some areas were held out, typically lands with recent site-specific approvals, large redevelopment areas, or places where the planning framework was still being worked out. For those parcels, the former by-laws simply kept running. In the old city that means 438-86.
The second group is subtler and catches more homeowners. Over the decades, hundreds of individual properties and small clusters in the old city got their own amending by-laws: a rezoning for a converted church, a townhouse infill on a former industrial lot, a house on a laneway with unusual permissions. When 569-2013 came in, many of those sites got exceptions in Chapter 900, and some of those exceptions say the old site-specific by-law prevails. So the house is technically in 569-2013, but the rules that matter for your addition, like height, setbacks or permitted floor area, come from a 438-86 amendment written twenty or thirty years ago.
The exception number on the zoning map is the most ignored piece of text in Toronto residential design. Read it before anyone draws a line.
Townhouse and infill sites are the usual suspects
If you own a townhouse in a small enclave built in the 1980s or 1990s, or a house on a lot that was carved out through a rezoning, assume there's a site-specific by-law until proven otherwise. Those by-laws often set a fixed building envelope, sometimes a maximum floor area for the whole block rather than for each unit. One owner adding a third-floor addition can eat into a limit that was meant to be shared, and the examiner will catch it.
Why Your Zoning Notice Might List Both By-laws
Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.
For years after 569-2013 was enacted, large parts of it were under appeal at the Ontario Municipal Board and then the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal. While those appeals were live, Toronto Building reviewed permit applications against both the new by-law and the former municipal by-law. Committee of Adjustment notices from that period list variances under 569-2013 and, separately, under 438-86. Plenty of homeowners still find those old notices when they research their neighbours' approvals and wonder why there are two lists.
Most of the city-wide by-law is now in force, so dual review is far less common for ordinary houses. It hasn't disappeared, though. Where a specific provision or a specific site is still tied up, or where a prevailing by-law governs some matters and 569-2013 governs the rest, the examiner can still test your plans against both. When that happens, you need to comply with both, or get variances from both. Passing one by-law doesn't excuse the other.
There are also transition provisions in 569-2013 that let certain applications filed before particular dates be reviewed under the older rules. Those have mostly run their course, but if you're reviving an old project, say a permit application that was filed years ago and stalled, ask Toronto Building directly whether any transition protection still applies. Don't assume it does.
The Numbers Don't Translate One to One
This is where projects get into trouble. People hear that the density on their street is 0.6 times the lot area under both by-laws and assume the math is the same. It isn't. The two by-laws define and measure things differently, so the same house can come out with different results.
- Gross floor area: what gets counted and what gets excluded (basements, attics, stairwells, garages, mechanical space) differs between the two by-laws. A finished basement or a converted attic can push you over under one and not the other.
- Height: the reference point for measuring height and the way roof features are treated are not identical. A flat-roof third storey that squeaks in under one can need a variance under the other.
- Building depth and rear additions: both by-laws limit how far a house can extend into the lot, but they measure it from different points and set different limits in many zones.
- Side yards: the old city rules were notoriously sensitive to windows and openings on side walls. A blank wall and a wall with a bedroom window can trigger very different setback requirements.
- Front yard and soft landscaping: requirements for landscaped open space and how a front pad or walkway counts against it changed between the by-laws.
We avoid quoting specific numbers here because they vary by zone, by exception and sometimes by street. The point is that your designer has to run the calculations under whichever by-law actually governs, using that by-law's definitions. Running 569-2013 math on a site controlled by a 438-86 amendment is one of the most common reasons we see drawings bounced at zoning review.
What This Means at the Committee of Adjustment
If your project needs relief, the Committee of Adjustment will hear variances under every by-law that applies. On a dual-review file, your application lists the 569-2013 variances and the 438-86 variances separately, and the public notice mailed to your neighbours shows both. That can look alarming to a neighbour skimming the notice: twelve variances sounds like a lot more than six, even when half of them are the same thing measured two ways.
Two practical consequences. First, the planning rationale has to address the four tests under the Planning Act for each variance, under each by-law. A cover letter that only argues the 569-2013 numbers leaves a gap that City Planning staff or an objecting neighbour can point to. Second, it's worth explaining in plain language in your submission, and in a conversation with neighbours before the hearing, that many of the listed variances describe the same physical element. The neighbour who shows up angry at the hearing is usually the one nobody talked to.
Old variances on your property
If a previous owner got minor variances under 438-86, for a rear addition or a front porch, for instance, those approvals were tied to a specific building and specific drawings. Whether they carry forward to protect that existing condition under 569-2013 depends on the transition and lawful-existing-building provisions, and it is very much a file-by-file question. They don't automatically authorize anything new. Bring the old decision to your zoning review so the examiner can see it.
Existing Houses That Don't Comply With Either By-law
Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.
Most houses in the old city were built long before 438-86, never mind 569-2013. Victorian and Edwardian row houses sit on narrow lots with almost no side yard and very little rear yard by modern standards. They're lawfully existing, so you don't need to fix those conditions just because the zoning changed. The trouble starts when you add to them.
Examiners look closely at whether your addition extends or worsens an existing non-complying condition. Raising a wall that's already too close to the side lot line, adding a storey on top of an existing side wall, or extending a rear wall in line with a non-complying side yard will typically need a variance. The analysis is similar under both by-laws, but the threshold numbers differ, so you can end up needing relief under one and not the other. On a dual-review site, assume you'll need to show compliance or variances both ways.
The Order We Work In Before Anyone Draws
After running a lot of old city files through Toronto Building, from Annex semis to Leslieville row houses, our sequence is fairly fixed, because getting the governing by-law wrong costs months, not days.
- Pull the zoning map entry and note the zone label, density, height and any exception number.
- Read the Chapter 900 exception in full, including any Prevailing By-laws and Prevailing Sections, and pull the old amending by-law if one is listed.
- Search past Committee of Adjustment decisions for the address and the street to see what's been approved and under which by-law.
- Run the existing house and the proposed design against every by-law that governs, using each by-law's own definitions.
- If anything is ambiguous, get a Preliminary Project Review or Zoning Certificate before finalizing drawings rather than discovering it at permit stage.
PermitsHub does this zoning review as the first step of every old city project, and when the answer is that both by-laws apply, we prepare the drawings and the variance list for both so the Committee of Adjustment application and the building permit submission line up. It's slower up front. It's much faster than redrawing after a zoning notice lands.
The short version: 438-86 is mostly history for a typical house in the former City of Toronto, but mostly isn't always. One exception number on the zoning map can decide which rulebook your addition is judged against, so check it before you commit to a design.
Do I Need a Permit?
What are you planning to build or renovate?
Ready to move forward? PermitsHub handles permit drawings, submission, and revisions - flat-rate, GTA-wide.