PermitsHubPermitsHub

By Area

Second-Storey Addition in Kensington Market (M5T) Heritage District

Yes, you can add a storey in Kensington Market, but a heritage permit and almost always a zoning variance come before the building permit. The narrow attached buildings and shops on the ground floor add party wall and fire separation work that a detached house addition never has to deal with. Here's the real sequence and where these projects stall.

By PermitsHub Team9 min read

Key Takeaways

  • A second-storey addition inside the Kensington Market Heritage Conservation District needs heritage approval from the City before Toronto Building will issue the building permit, and the design usually has to step back from the street face to get it.
  • Most Kensington lots already exceed today's zoning limits for coverage, density or setbacks, so plan on a Committee of Adjustment application running alongside the heritage review.
  • On attached rowhouses the party wall has to be carried up as a proper fire-rated wall, and a shop on the ground floor means a separate fire separation between the commercial space and the homes above.
  • Chinatown buildings in M5T are mostly outside the Kensington district boundary, but some are individually listed or designated, so check the heritage register before assuming you only need a building permit.

Kensington Rooflines, One Storey Up

Yes, you can add a second storey to a building in Kensington Market, but it's a three-layer approval, not a one-step permit. Because the area is a heritage conservation district under Part V of the Ontario Heritage Act, the addition first needs heritage approval from the City's Heritage Planning staff. Most projects also need minor variances from the Committee of Adjustment, because the lots are tiny and the buildings already break modern zoning rules. Only after both are settled will Toronto Building issue the building permit, and that permit review brings its own issues on attached rowhouses and mixed-use buildings: party walls, fire separations and shops on the ground floor.

That's the short answer. The longer one is about what the heritage plan actually cares about, why the zoning almost never works as-of-right, and why the building code review on a Kensington semi or row is a different animal from a detached house in North York.

First, confirm your building is inside the district and how it's classified

The Kensington Market HCD covers the market blocks west of Spadina, roughly between College and Dundas. The boundary isn't a neat rectangle, though. Some streets at the edges are in and some aren't, so check the address against the City's heritage district mapping before anything else. The HCD plan's status and policies have been through appeals over the years, so confirm with Heritage Planning which version applies to your property.

Inside the district, the plan sorts properties into contributing and non-contributing. A contributing property is one whose form, age or character supports the district's heritage value: the Victorian bay-and-gable rowhouses on Augusta, Kensington and Baldwin, the old houses with storefronts pushed out to the sidewalk. Contributing buildings get the closest scrutiny. A non-contributing building still needs heritage approval for an addition, but the conversation is mostly about fitting the streetscape, not keeping original fabric.

What about Chinatown?

M5T also covers Chinatown along Spadina and Dundas, and most of those buildings fall outside the Kensington district. That doesn't mean they're free of heritage control. A number of buildings in the area are individually listed or designated on the City's Heritage Register. A listed property mainly triggers a notice period if you're demolishing. A designated property needs heritage consent for alterations, much like a district property. Search the address on the register before you assume it's a straight building permit.

What the heritage review actually looks at on an addition

Heritage staff aren't trying to stop people from adding space. They care about what the addition does to the street. In Kensington that comes down to a handful of things they ask about on almost every file.

  • Setback from the front wall: a new storey that sits flush with the facade reads as a different building, so staff usually push it back so it's less visible from the sidewalk.
  • Height relative to neighbours: on a row of matching two-storey houses, one unit jumping up a full floor breaks the roofline that the plan is trying to protect.
  • Roof form: losing a front gable or a mansard on a contributing house is a much harder conversation than building behind it.
  • Materials and windows: brick, cladding and window proportions should sit comfortably next to the old building without faking it.
  • Retention of front elements: bays, cornices, original brick and storefront features are expected to stay.

Expect a Heritage Impact Assessment or a heritage-focused design rationale on contributing properties, prepared by someone qualified to write one. Smaller, well-set-back additions can often be approved by staff under delegated authority. Bigger or more contentious ones can go to the Toronto Preservation Board and City Council, which adds months. The fastest files we see are the ones where the drawings went to Heritage Planning for a pre-consultation before the design was locked.

In Kensington, the heritage file is won or lost on one line in the section drawing: how far back from the front wall the new storey starts.

The order of approvals before Toronto Building will issue a permit

Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.

Heritage approval counts as applicable law under the Building Code Act, so the plan examiner can't issue the building permit until it's in place. Same for any Committee of Adjustment decision that has become final. Here's the sequence that tends to work on Kensington files:

  • Survey and measured drawings of the existing building, including the neighbours' walls and rooflines where you can see them.
  • Zoning review against Toronto's Zoning By-law 569-2013 to find every variance the addition triggers, so you file once, not twice.
  • Pre-consultation with Heritage Planning on the massing before detailed design.
  • Heritage permit application and, if needed, a Committee of Adjustment application. Heritage staff comment on the variance application, so the two have to tell the same story.
  • Building permit application with architectural, structural and fire separation drawings once the heritage and variance decisions are in hand.
  • Street occupancy permits for scaffolding or bins, then construction and inspections.

You can submit the building permit while the variance is pending to get the plan review moving, but the permit won't issue until everything clears. If the Committee or heritage staff ask for changes, the permit drawings get revised to match. That's why it pays to settle the massing early.

Zoning in M5T: why nearly every addition here needs a variance

Kensington was built long before zoning existed. Houses sit on lots that are often well under the widths you see in newer neighbourhoods, with zero side setbacks, very shallow rear yards and, on many market streets, a one-storey storefront built right out to the sidewalk where the front yard used to be. Much of the area is zoned Commercial Residential, with residential zoning on some of the quieter side streets. Either way, the existing building is almost always legal non-conforming for something.

Adding a floor usually trips at least one of these: maximum height, density (floor space index), building depth, setbacks, or rear yard soft landscaping. Under the CR zones, density and height limits vary by block, so check the specific numbers on your property's zoning before you sketch anything. A Committee of Adjustment application for several variances is normal here. The Committee is asking whether the variances are minor, desirable, and in keeping with the Official Plan and zoning intent, and on a heritage street the heritage staff comment carries real weight.

Neighbours matter more than usual. Kensington residents and local groups follow development closely, and a new storey on an attached row casts shadow into very small backyards. Talk to the people sharing your party walls before the Committee notice lands in their mailbox. Objections at a hearing are much easier to answer when you already know what they are.

Party walls, fire separation and the shop downstairs

This is where a Kensington addition stops looking like a typical second-storey job. On a detached house, the new walls are your walls. On a semi or a row, one or both sides are shared with a neighbour, and the Ontario Building Code requires the wall between dwelling units to be a fire separation with the required fire-resistance rating, carried continuously up through the new storey and properly sealed at the roof.

In practice, the old party wall is often a single wythe of soft Victorian brick, or brick that changes to wood framing in the attic. Plan examiners will want to see exactly how the new wall above the existing roofline is built, how it connects to the old wall below, and how the roof assembly meets it. If your new floor stands higher than the neighbour's roof, the exposed side wall now faces their roof at zero distance, which brings spatial separation rules into play. That limits or rules out windows on that side, and often calls for noncombustible cladding.

When there's a store on the ground floor

Many Kensington buildings are a shop or restaurant with apartments above. Adding a storey to a mixed-use building means the code treats it as two occupancies: mercantile or assembly below, residential above. You need a rated fire separation between them, protected exits for the residential units that don't pass through the store, and attention to how ducts, gas lines and kitchen exhaust from a restaurant pass through the separation. Depending on the building's size and the occupancies involved, the design can move outside the simpler Part 9 house rules, and some mixed-use buildings require an architect to seal the drawings rather than a qualified designer. Confirm that with your designer before you start, not after the examiner asks.

Structure is the other surprise. Old Kensington houses often sit on rubble or brick foundations with undersized floor joists, and many were renovated piecemeal over a century. An engineer has to show that the walls and foundation can carry the new floor, and the answer is often new steel posts, footings or underpinning at specific points. Opening up the walls during construction regularly turns up conditions that need a revised structural detail, so budget time for at least one field revision.

Building it on a street with no room to work

Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.

The market streets are narrow, sidewalks are crowded, and most lots have no laneway access. Scaffolding, a bin or a material hoist will usually sit on City sidewalk or roadway, which needs a street occupancy permit from Transportation Services. On market streets, delivery windows and pedestrian traffic shape the whole construction schedule. Roofing and framing the party wall from the outside often means standing on, or at least working over, the neighbour's roof. Ontario gives you no automatic right to go onto adjoining property, so a written access agreement with the neighbour belongs on your list before the permit issues.

Inspections follow the normal Toronto Building sequence (framing, insulation, fire separation, final), but on attached buildings the inspector will pay close attention to fire stopping at the party wall and the occupancy separation. Leave those areas open until the inspection is passed. Closing up drywall early is one of the more common reasons a Kensington job loses a week.

What a design that gets approved tends to look like

The additions that move through heritage, the Committee and plan review with the fewest rounds share a few traits. The new storey starts well back from the front wall, so the original facade and roofline still read from the street. The massing is held to the rear half of the building, where it's less visible and casts less shadow on the street. The party wall details are drawn properly from the first submission rather than sketched. On mixed-use buildings, the residential entrance and exit path is figured out before the floor plans, because it drives everything else.

We've worked on rowhouse and mixed-use files across the downtown west end, Kensington included, and the pattern holds. If you want the heritage, zoning and code issues mapped on one set of drawings before you commit, PermitsHub can prepare the measured drawings, run the zoning review against By-law 569-2013 and coordinate the heritage and building permit submissions so the drawings each reviewer sees actually match.

Do I Need a Permit?

1
›
2
›
3
›
4

What are you planning to build or renovate?

Ready to move forward? PermitsHub handles permit drawings, submission, and revisions - flat-rate, GTA-wide.

Related Reading

More in this category

By Area

FAQ

Related questions

Get started

Tell us about your project.

Free, no-pressure quote within one business day.

● Flat-rate quotes - no surprise fees

● Revisions included until approval

● Most enquiries responded to same day

Free Home Permit QuoteNo commitment · 30 sec
1
2
3

What are you building?

SCROLL TO SEE ALL 20 PERMIT TYPES

Prefer to call? 647-961-4070
CALL NOWFree Home Permit Quote30 SECONDS - NO COMMITMENT