Additions
Adding a Rear Addition to a Scarborough Side-Split With Staggered Floors
The back of a Scarborough side-split sits on two or three floor levels, and a rear addition can only match one of them. That choice sets your stairs, your roof tie-in and how deep the footings go. If there's a basement apartment, it can also bury a bedroom window that the plan examiner will want relocated.
Key Takeaways
- Choose which existing floor level the addition will match before any design work starts, because that one decision fixes the stair layout, the roof tie-in and the footing depth.
- Matching the kitchen level gives you a step-free extension of the main living space, but the floor ends up well above rear grade and the new roof has to stay below the bedroom window sills next door.
- New footings beside a side-split's stepped existing footings must reach frost depth without undermining the shallower sections, which sometimes means localized underpinning or stepped footings designed by an engineer.
- If the addition covers a basement apartment bedroom window, that window no longer opens to the outdoors, so it has to be relocated or the room reclassified, and the Scarborough district office will check this on the drawings.
Matching the Right Level
On a Scarborough side-split, a rear addition has to commit to one of the house's existing floor levels, usually the kitchen level or the lower family room level. That single decision drives how many stairs you need inside the addition, how the new roof meets two different wall heights, and how deep the new footings have to go. If the house has a basement apartment, check before you design anything whether the addition will cover a rear bedroom window. A buried egress window has to be relocated, and the plan examiner at the Scarborough district office will look for that on the drawings.
Side-splits are everywhere in Scarborough, and they are good houses to extend. But the half-levels that make them comfortable to live in also make them awkward to add onto. A rear addition on a plain bungalow is mostly a question of size. On a side-split it starts as a question of height.
What the Back of a Scarborough Side-Split Actually Looks Like
Most of the side-splits in Wexford, Dorset Park, Bendale, Clairlea, Agincourt and Guildwood went up between the mid 1950s and the 1970s. The layout is close to identical from street to street. You come in the front door at the main level with the living room, dining room and kitchen. A half flight up takes you to the bedrooms. A half flight down from the entry takes you to a family room tucked under the bedroom wing, usually partly below grade with windows just above the ground. Below the family room, or below the kitchen, there's often a basement or a crawlspace.
From the backyard, that reads as two different walls. On one side is the kitchen wall with a door that opens onto a deck or landing several steps above the yard. On the other side is a taller wall with family room windows near the ground and bedroom windows above them. The roofs are separate too: a low gable over the kitchen and living wing, and a higher roof over the bedroom wing. Any addition across the back has to deal with all of that.
So the first job is measuring, not designing. When PermitsHub draws existing conditions on a side-split, and we've done a lot of them across Wexford, Dorset Park and Bendale, we take actual heights rather than assuming the half-levels are evenly split. They rarely are. Settlement, later renovations and sloping lots mean the drop from kitchen to family room can vary by several inches from one house to the next on the same street.
- Finished floor height of each level relative to a single fixed point, so the drawings show the real difference between them.
- Grade along the full rear wall, which on many Scarborough lots slopes toward the back or to one side.
- Sill height of every rear window on every level, especially the bedroom windows above the family room.
- Eave height and roof slope of both the kitchen wing and the bedroom wing.
- Location and size of any basement windows and window wells, and which rooms they serve.
Three Ways to Attach: Picking the Level the Addition Will Match
Match the kitchen level
This is the most common choice, because most owners want a bigger kitchen or a family room that opens straight off it with no steps. It works well inside. Outside, the new floor sits several feet above the yard, so the addition needs either a crawlspace or a full basement underneath, plus a stair or deck down to grade from the new back door. The other catch is the bedroom wing beside it. A kitchen-level addition that runs across the full width of the house puts its roof right under the bedroom windows, and the roof has to stay below those sills with room for flashing and insulation.
Match the lower family room level
Dropping the addition to the family room level puts it close to grade, which means an easy walkout to the yard, less exposed foundation wall and a roof that sits comfortably below the bedroom windows. The cost is the connection to the kitchen. You either reach the addition through the existing family room or you put a stair inside the addition to step down from the kitchen. Under the Ontario Building Code, each riser in a house stair can be no taller than 200 mm and each run no shorter than 210 mm, so a half-level drop needs several risers plus landing space at the top and bottom. That stair takes floor area out of the room you're paying to build.
Follow the house: split or two-storey additions
Some owners build the addition in two sections, one at each level, or put a two-storey addition behind the bedroom wing that extends both the family room and a bedroom above it. These can produce the best floor plans, but they bring more complicated roofs, more scrutiny on height and main wall limits, and a much higher chance of neighbours raising privacy concerns about upper windows overlooking their yards.
On a side-split, the level you pick on day one decides the stairs, the roof and the footings. Changing it after the drawings are done means starting the drawings over.
Tying the Roof Into Two Different Wall Heights
Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.
A full-width addition meets the low kitchen eave on one side and the tall bedroom wing wall on the other. The simplest answer is usually a flat or low-slope roof with a membrane, tucked under the kitchen eave and running up against the bedroom wing wall. It keeps the roof under the bedroom sills and avoids building a new valley into an old roof.
That lower roof sitting against a taller wall is exactly where wind drifts snow. The Building Code requires the designer to account for drift loads in that zone, which usually means heavier joists or closer spacing along the wall of the bedroom wing. Drawings that size the whole roof for basic snow load and ignore the drift are one of the things plan examiners send back. Flashing is the other weak point. Original Scarborough brick veneer needs counterflashing cut into the mortar joints, and where the house has been re-clad in siding, the membrane has to turn up behind it, not stop at its face.
Opening up the old rear wall matters as much as the new roof. The kitchen's rear wall often carries ceiling joists or rafters, and a wide opening into the addition needs a beam with its point loads carried down to proper footings. In a side-split those loads can land right where the existing foundation changes depth, which leads straight into the next problem.
Foundations When the Existing Footings Sit at Different Depths
The back wall of a side-split usually sits on stepped footings: deep under any basement, shallower under the family room, and sometimes quite shallow under a kitchen crawlspace. New footings must be at least frost depth below finished grade, which in the Toronto area is generally taken as 1.2 m. On a sloping lot, that depth is measured from the grade at the new wall, not from the front of the house.
The risk comes when the new footing ends up deeper than the old one beside it. Dig a full basement under a kitchen-level addition next to a crawlspace footing and you can undermine the existing wall. The usual fixes are stepped footings that transition gradually, or underpinning a short section of the existing foundation where the two meet. Either way, an engineer should design that junction, and the inspector will want to see it before the concrete goes in.
- Addition at kitchen level over a crawlspace: shallowest excavation, but the crawlspace still needs frost-depth footings and proper ventilation or conditioning.
- Addition at kitchen level over a full basement: most usable space, deepest dig, most likely to need work where it meets shallower existing footings.
- Addition at family room level on a slab or short frost wall: least excavation and simplest junction, as long as the existing family room footing is at frost depth.
- Any lot backing onto Highland Creek, the Rouge valley or the bluffs: check whether TRCA regulates the property before committing to a footprint.
When the Addition Buries a Basement Apartment Window
A lot of Scarborough side-splits have an apartment in the basement or on the lower level, and the bedrooms in those units usually rely on rear windows in window wells. The Building Code requires a bedroom to have a window that opens from the inside to the outdoors without tools, with an unobstructed opening of at least 0.35 square metres and no dimension under 380 mm, unless the suite has another compliant way out such as sprinklers or an exterior door from that area. Once an addition is built over or in front of that window, it opens into the addition instead of to the outdoors. It no longer counts.
There are four realistic fixes, and none of them is free of trade-offs. You can relocate the window to a side wall, which only works if the side yard is wide enough for a window well and doesn't clash with a side entrance stair or the neighbour's fence line. You can build a basement under the addition and give the bedroom a new compliant window in the new foundation wall. You can narrow the addition so it stops short of the window. Or you can turn that room into something other than a bedroom, which reduces the unit and has to be shown honestly on the drawings.
The Scarborough district office of Toronto Building, at the Scarborough Civic Centre, will expect the basement floor plans to show the existing suite and what happens to that window. Examiners see a lot of side-splits with suites and they know where those bedrooms usually are. If the suite was never permitted, the addition application tends to surface it, and you may end up legalizing the unit as part of the job, including fire separations and interconnected smoke alarms between the units, before the addition permit can close.
What Gets Flagged at Zoning Review and Committee of Adjustment
Have a project in mind? Get an honest, no-pressure permit review from PermitsHub.
Rear additions on Scarborough side-splits get caught on a predictable set of zoning items. City-wide Zoning By-law 569-2013 applies to most of these lots, but some properties still carry provisions from the former Scarborough bylaws, so the applicable rules need to be confirmed for your specific address before design starts.
- Building depth and rear yard setback, which a deep addition on a shallow lot can exceed quickly.
- Lot coverage, especially when there's already a detached garage or shed at the back.
- Height and main wall height, measured from established grade, which gets complicated on sloping lots and with two-storey additions.
- Platform and deck height off a kitchen-level back door, since a raised landing can trigger its own setback limits.
- Side yard setbacks where the addition is wider than the existing house.
If any of these need relief, the application goes to the Committee of Adjustment's Scarborough panel for a minor variance before Toronto Building will issue the permit. In our experience, one-storey additions at kitchen or family room level rarely draw serious objections. Two-storey additions with bedroom windows facing the neighbours' yards are a different story, and it's worth showing neighbours the drawings early.
Sequencing the Build So the House Stays Livable
If there are tenants downstairs, the order of work matters. The relocated egress window or the new foundation window should be cut and finished before the addition closes in over the old one, so the bedroom is never left without a legal way out. Excavation for a deep footing next to a basement unit needs to be planned with the tenants in mind, because that's the side of the house where the noise, dust and shoring will be.
On our side-split files, PermitsHub settles the level choice, the zoning review and the suite window plan before the addition design is finalized. That way the drawings that go to the Scarborough district office answer the examiner's questions about levels, drift loads, footings and egress the first time, and revisions don't hold up the start date. With that groundwork done, a side-split addition is a very buildable project, and the staggered floors can produce a better plan than a flat bungalow would.
Do I Need a Permit?
What are you planning to build or renovate?
Ready to move forward? PermitsHub handles permit drawings, submission, and revisions - flat-rate, GTA-wide.